Skip to content

Judging and public voting

Good work. Backed by evidence.

Independent judges contribute 80% of the final score. Verified public votes contribute 20%.

A short guide · 37 seconds

Vote and add an example

A simple vote counts. A written example is optional and helps judges understand the work.

Read the transcript

Want to support someone’s nomination? Open their public page and use your own NHS or HSC work email to vote. Your email won’t appear on their profile, or be shared with the nominee or the judges.

We’ll send you a link. Open it, then confirm your vote before voting closes. There’s no password to remember, and you don’t need to write a statement.

If you’ve seen their work first-hand, you can add an example afterwards. A few specific details about what they did, and the difference it made, can help the judges. Please leave out patient details and anything confidential.

A good nomination should help judges understand what happened, what the nominee contributed and what changed. It should also be honest about what the evidence cannot show.

From contribution to assessment

  1. Nomination and acceptance. The nominator confirms their email address. The nominee accepts the invitation and checks the entry.
  2. An evidence case. The nominee and relevant contributors provide examples, outcomes and supporting material.
  3. Review and moderation. Public material is checked before publication. Verification labels explain what has been checked; they do not guarantee every claim is correct.
  4. Independent assessment. Eligible judges assess the evidence against published category criteria and weightings.
  5. Approval and publication. Completed assessments, disagreements and missing evidence are reviewed before an authorised administrator approves results.

Conflicts of interest

Judges declare conflicts before accessing an allocated case. A potential or confirmed conflict prevents that judge from assessing the entry. Conflicts remain relevant in later judging rounds.

How the 80 / 20 score works

The judges’ weighted mean mark out of 10 is multiplied by eight, giving up to 80 points. In each category, the eligible submitted entry with the most valid votes receives 20 public points. Other entries receive a proportional share: half as many votes gives 10 points. These are added to the judges’ points.

For example, a judge mark of 8 out of 10 gives 64 points. If that entry has half the votes of the leading eligible entry, it receives 10 public points, for a combined score of 74 out of 100. If no eligible entry in a category has valid votes, judges provide the full score out of 100.

Entries still need to meet the category requirements and submit evidence. Ties, missing assessments and any exception to the combined ranking require a recorded panel decision before results are approved. The same voting total is used in both judging rounds; voting does not reopen for finalists. In the final round, public points are calculated between the published finalists.

Cast a vote, with evidence if you wish

Use the nominee’s public page and confirm the link sent to your individual NHS or HSC work email. No password or written statement is required to vote. Each confirmed address can vote once per entry, and can support more than one nominee. You cannot vote for your own entry or use a shared mailbox.

Accepted email families include nhs.net, NHS organisation addresses ending in nhs.uk, nhs.scot and hscni.net. Email verification confirms access to that mailbox, not someone’s profession or identity. Your email is never shown publicly or shared with the nominee or judges.

Voting closes at the published evidence deadline, or earlier if the category closes. Confirmation must be completed before voting closes. Votes are checked for duplicates and abuse; invalid votes are excluded with a recorded reason. You can sign in to withdraw your vote.

After voting, you can optionally add a specific example of the nominee’s work. Written contributions are judged on their content; submitting evidence does not cast an extra vote. Confidential material and patient details must not be included.

Commercial independence

Supporters help promote the awards. Sponsors may provide financial support. Neither role buys influence over scoring or award status, or grants access to private evidence.

The organiser and commonly owned organisations cannot win where this creates a conflict. Before a winner is approved, a separate administrator records the ownership checks and sources. A changed decision withdraws the earlier winner approval. Commercial relationships never override this check.

Responsible use of technology

Source extracts can help judges find relevant evidence. Any AI-assisted extracts are labelled and linked to the original material. AI does not score entries or choose winners.

Start with the work

Know someone who deserves recognition?

Find the right category and see what makes a useful nomination.

Prepare a nomination